Cincinnati Coalition for IsraelDONATE
All posts

Cincinnati Coalition for Israel

"Anti-Zionism Isn't Antisemitism" — and 4 Other Lines Cincinnati Upstanders Should Be Ready to Answer

September 29, 2026

"Anti-Zionism Isn't Antisemitism", and 4 Other Lines Cincinnati Upstanders Should Be Ready to Answer

American and Israeli flags representing partnership and shared democratic values

You have probably heard one of these lines in a classroom, at work, online, or around the dinner table:

  • “Anti-Zionism isn’t antisemitism.”
  • “I’m not antisemitic. I’m just anti-Israel.”
  • “The IHRA definition outlaws criticism of Israel.”
  • “It’s a both-sides problem.”
  • “Why is this the only hate you care about?”

These statements can sound reasonable at first. They often arrive wrapped in the language of human rights, fairness, or political disagreement. That is why you need more than outrage. You need clarity.

We are not asking you to shout people down. We are asking you to answer with calm confidence, moral seriousness, and facts.

The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance working definition of antisemitism recognizes that antisemitism can appear in traditional anti-Jewish hatred, and in rhetoric about Israel when it denies Jewish self-determination, applies double standards, uses classic antisemitic accusations, or holds Jews collectively responsible for the actions of the Israeli government.

The IHRA definition also makes an important distinction: criticism of Israel similar to criticism directed at any other country is not, by itself, antisemitic.

That distinction matters. So does the courage to defend it.

1. “Anti-Zionism isn’t antisemitism.”

What you’ll hear

“Zionism is a political ideology. I oppose it. That does not make me antisemitic.”

Why it lands wrong

It is true that criticizing a government or political movement is not automatically antisemitic. Jewish people, like everyone else, are not required to agree about Israeli policy, leadership, military decisions, or peace proposals.

But “anti-Zionism” often means more than criticism. It can mean opposition to the existence of Israel as a Jewish homeland and denial of the Jewish people’s right to national self-determination.

That is the key distinction.

The IHRA examples identify as potentially antisemitic the claim that Israel’s existence is inherently a racist endeavor or the denial of Jewish self-determination. Context matters, but the underlying principle is clear. Singling out Jews as the one people who may not have a national home is not a neutral political position.

What you can say back

“I agree that Israeli policies can be criticized. But criticism of a government is different from denying the Jewish people the right to self-determination. Are you opposing a policy, or are you saying Israel should not exist as a Jewish state at all?”

You can also say:

“If you oppose all nation-states or all forms of nationalism consistently, explain that standard clearly. But if Jews alone are denied the right to national self-determination, that is a discriminatory double standard.”

Keep the focus on the principle, not the person. Ask what someone means. Make them define their position. Do not let vague language hide an extreme demand.

American flag flying above an Ohio civic building on an overcast morning

2. “I’m not antisemitic. I’m just anti-Israel.”

What you’ll hear

“I have nothing against Jewish people. I only oppose Israel.”

Why it lands wrong

Sometimes this statement means, “I oppose a specific Israeli government action.” That can be a legitimate political view.

But “Israel” can be used as a substitute for “Jews,” especially when people demand that Jewish neighbors, students, employees, or religious institutions answer for actions taken by a government thousands of miles away.

That is not criticism. That is collective blame.

The IHRA working definition specifically identifies holding Jews collectively responsible for the actions of the State of Israel as a possible manifestation of antisemitism. A Jewish American is not the Israeli government. A synagogue is not the Israeli military. A Jewish student is not a spokesperson for every decision made in Jerusalem.

What you can say back

“You can criticize the Israeli government. But Jewish people in Cincinnati are not collectively responsible for Israel’s policies. Please criticize the decision-makers you mean, and do not target local Jews or Jewish institutions because of their identity.”

Or:

“What would you say if an American Muslim were held responsible for the actions of a Muslim-majority government? What would you say if every Christian church were blamed for a Christian-majority country’s policies? Apply the same standard here.”

This is where language matters. Do not accept “Zionist” as a coded substitute for “Jew.” Do not accept harassment of Jewish students or vandalism of Jewish institutions as political commentary.

Criticism belongs in civic debate. Collective blame belongs nowhere.

3. “The IHRA definition outlaws criticism of Israel.”

What you’ll hear

“The IHRA definition is a censorship tool. It means you cannot criticize Israel.”

Why it lands wrong

The IHRA definition does not say that all criticism of Israel is antisemitic. In fact, it expressly states that criticism similar to criticism directed at any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic.

The definition provides a framework for recognizing when anti-Israel rhetoric may cross into antisemitism, especially when it uses demonization, delegitimization, double standards, classic anti-Jewish tropes, or collective blame.

That is guidance, not a ban on disagreement.

Ohio Senate Bill 87 is part of this public debate. The bill would codify an IHRA-based definition for use in specified civil and administrative contexts and related investigations. As of this writing, SB 87 has passed the Ohio Senate and remains under consideration in the Ohio House. It is not a standalone crime of “antisemitism,” and it does not make criticism of Israel a criminal offense.

Follow the official Ohio Legislature bill page for the current status and text.

What you can say back

“The IHRA definition protects legitimate criticism by drawing a line between policy criticism and antisemitic targeting. It does not say Israel is beyond criticism. It says Jews should not be demonized, collectively blamed, or denied rights that other peoples possess.”

If someone raises free speech, answer directly:

“Free speech protects the right to express political opinions. It does not require the public to ignore discrimination, harassment, or antisemitic conduct. Naming hate is not censorship.”

Learn the facts. Read the definition. Read the bill. Then speak accurately.

4. “It’s a both-sides problem.”

What you’ll hear

“Everyone in the conflict has done terrible things. Both sides are guilty, so why focus on antisemitism?”

Why it lands wrong

The suffering of Palestinian civilians matters. So does the safety of Israeli civilians. Supporting Israel’s right to exist does not require indifference to Palestinian human rights, and concern for Palestinian civilians does not excuse antisemitism or terrorism.

But “both sides” can become a way to avoid naming a specific act of hatred.

If a Jewish student is harassed, address the harassment. If a synagogue is vandalized, address the vandalism. If someone uses Nazi imagery or blames Jews in Cincinnati for the conduct of the Israeli government, address that conduct.

Moral clarity does not require pretending that every issue is identical. It requires identifying the wrong in front of you.

What you can say back

“We can care about more than one injustice at the same time. Palestinian civilians deserve safety and dignity. Jewish people deserve safety and dignity. Discussing one does not erase the other, and antisemitism should not be excused because the Middle East is complicated.”

Or:

“A complicated conflict does not make local hatred acceptable. We can debate policy while still rejecting harassment, threats, and collective blame.”

Compassion is not a limited resource. Neither is accountability.

Cincinnati community members standing together at a riverside vigil holding small American and Israeli flags

5. “Why is this the only hate you care about?”

What you’ll hear

“There are so many forms of hate. Why are you so focused on antisemitism?”

Why it lands wrong

This question may be sincere. It may also be an attempt to change the subject.

Our answer is simple: we care about combating antisemitism because that is part of our mission, and because every community needs people willing to confront the hatred they see.

The Cincinnati Coalition for Israel’s mission is focused on combating antisemitism, promoting civic education, strengthening the U.S.–Israel partnership, and opposing hate through lawful advocacy and community engagement.

That focus does not diminish other communities. It demonstrates responsibility.

What you can say back

“I care about fighting all forms of hate. Today, I am speaking about antisemitism because I am seeing it, because Jewish neighbors are experiencing it, and because silence allows it to spread.”

You can add:

“You do not have to choose between opposing antisemitism and opposing racism, Islamophobia, anti-Black hatred, anti-Christian persecution, or any other form of bigotry. We should confront all of it.”

Then turn the conversation toward action. Ask the person to join you in rejecting hate consistently.

BE AN UPSTANDER. USE YOUR VOICE.

You do not need a degree in international relations to answer antisemitism. You need honesty, patience, and the willingness to ask one clear question:

Is this criticism of a policy, or a denial of Jewish rights?

Start today:

  1. Learn the facts. Review the CCFI links and resources page, including educational and advocacy organizations.
  2. Follow Ohio’s legislative process. Read the current text and status of Ohio Senate Bill 87.
  3. Join the community. Check upcoming CCFI events and bring a friend.
  4. Share this guide. Give someone a calm, practical response before the next difficult conversation happens.
  5. Support the work. Donate to Cincinnati Coalition for Israel so volunteers can continue educating, advocating, and standing with our community.

We are not asking you to win every argument.

We are asking you not to surrender the truth.

Silence is not neutrality when hatred is being normalized.

Speak clearly. Stand respectfully. Act today.

Stand with your community.

Get coalition updates by email, or see the latest action on Ohio Senate Bill 87.